1)
2) Let your manufacturer’s
operating report inspire you
You likely prepare and send an operating
report to your manufacturer every month.
How you use the report beyond sending it
to the factory can have a big impact on your
dealership’s profitability. Here are some ideas
for using your monthly operating report as a
tool to stay on track as the year progresses.
Keeping an eye on revenue
Every manufacturer’s report is different, but
yours likely contains, in some format, a summary of that month’s operating revenue. These
figures can quickly tell you which departments
are the moneymakers and which lag behind
expectations.
Let’s say that the January 2012 operating
report for Joe Shiny’s North Side Auto shows
that it brought in the following in gross revenues: $2 million in new car sales, $750,000
in used car sales, $140,000 in parts sales,
$61,000 in service income and $56,000 in
body shop income.
Joe also can see how income from his store’s
various departments compares with the prior
month, January 2011, his projected budget,
benchmarks and so on. Let’s assume that Joe
had projected $2.25 million in new car sales
for January. With sales coming in at only
$2 million, Joe is concerned that first quarter
sales are off to a slow start and, thus, chooses
to move up by several weeks a new car sales
promotion he had planned to run in March.
2
Another example involves gross revenue vs.
turnover. Take Dealer A, who buys a vehicle for
$20,000, holds it for 90 days and finally sells it,
making a $3,000 gross profit. Many dealers
would be pleased with this outcome. But let’s
also consider Dealer B, who spends the same
$20,000, sells the vehicle in 30 days but only
achieves a 10% profit margin, or $2,000 gross
profit. The difference is that Dealer B does
three times the sales in the same 90 days,
doubling his total gross income compared to
Dealer A!
There are many other ways to use your operating report to analyze front-end operations.
Figuring out the reasons why
The reasons behind the numbers also are
important to consider. When you analyze the
back end of your operations, for example,
you’ll look at income and expenses in the
service, parts and body shop departments.
Let’s say that you have a gross profit of
$33,000 in the service department. This
alarms your manufacturer, because it’s less
than 55% of your monthly service sales and
shows that your gross profit percentage
3) has slipped from the target of 65%. But it
shouldn’t be a major concern if the reason
for the shortfall is that the department was
busier than usual refurbishing used cars for
sale in January — and profits for that venture
won’t start showing up until February.
Considering other benchmarks
Monthly operating reports are also a way for
you to measure your dealership’s performance
against more complex benchmarks. Consider,
for instance, the concept of “service absorption.” This is defined as the sum of total parts,
service and body shop gross profits divided
by the sum of total fixed expenses plus dealer
salary plus parts, service and body shop sales
expense. (If your report doesn’t have this category, you could calculate it from the other
data provided.)
Let’s say that your store’s benchmark range
for service absorption is 85% to 100%, but
your January operating report shows your
store coming in at 83.8% for the month. This
figure is only slightly below the bottom of
your benchmark range. Nonetheless, you
might want to take steps to lower expenses
or bump up revenue for the next month to
be sure your store is in the benchmark range.
Achieving a service absorption of 85% or
higher will give you a competitive advantage
over your competition, because the new and
used departments only need to cover 15% or
less of your dealership’s total fixed expenses.
Thus, you can afford to take less gross profit
on an individual sale.
All in all
By studying your manufacturer’s operating
reports, you can arrive at countless insights,
from your days’ supply of vehicles to the
gross profit per technician, to determine an
adequate employee count in the back end.
All of this knowledge can be golden, because
it helps you recognize strengths, pinpoint
weaknesses and set goals for the rest of the
year. Don’t let it go unnoticed. n
3 ways to keep cash flowing
Business owners know the importance of
having sufficient cash on hand to meet daily
needs and obligations. Here are three tips for
managing the flow of cash at your dealership.
1. Stay organized
Maintaining an organized system for cash
accounts is essential to strong cash-flow management. Keep at least two bank accounts —
one for general funds and one for payroll.
With Internet access to bank statements, your
accounting department should reconcile the
accounts daily for timeliness and precision.
Small daily overages and shortages aren’t
uncommon. Set aside any discovered variances in cash deposits each day in a separate
general ledger account. Review and reconcile
this account monthly, too.
A large percentage of cash can come in
through contracts-in-transit. Maintain only
one general ledger account for these transactions. Any division of this account allows for
additional, unnecessary entries and greater
room for error.
3
4) inventory turnover rates or costs per vehicle. If
unordered vehicles — especially trucks (given
their low marketability right now) — show up
on your lot, send them back to the factory.
3. Be quick to collect
Collecting money due to you is crucial to
cash flow. To free up cash, process a sale as
soon as possible. Collect all contract balances
within five days and investigate all credit balances. Time lags can tie up a large amount
of cash. And, remember, the “true worth” of
accounts receivable worsens as time passes.
2. Keep the lid on inventory
Your dealership’s largest operating asset —
your new, used and parts inventory — demands
your ongoing attention. First, address control
issues. Count inventory on a regular basis and
compare physical counts to accounting records.
Locate missing, damaged or inaccurately priced
items. Implement and enforce internal controls
to limit opportunities for employee theft.
Then delve into inventory aging. Each day
a vehicle sits on your lot, it incurs floor plan
interest, rent, insurance and security expenses.
Identify slow-moving vehicles. Chances are,
manufacturer floor plan assistance has run out.
Discount the price or offer in-house incentives to move these vehicles. As a last resort,
wholesale or auction the vehicle.
Parts inventory also drains cash and risks
obsolescence. In a pinch, a nearby dealership
or a local parts store can supply your imminent parts needs. So, keep your inventory as
lean as possible.
Closely monitor nonstock (special order)
parts to ensure they’re billed out on the corresponding repair orders. If these parts go
unused, use your manufacturer’s parts return
allowance to get rid of them.
Finally, formalize your ordering policies. A limited number of individuals should be authorized
to order inventory. Tie the pay plans of these
employees to inventory benchmarks, such as
4
You can determine the average time it takes
for funds to be received and when floor plan
payments are due. Three to five days is the
benchmark for processing contracts in transit.
Strong management and the use of checklists
will minimize errors leading to funding delays.
Closely monitoring receivables can help free
up cash and save you money in the long run.
Your computer system likely lets you print
summary receivable reports so you can thoroughly review account aging.
You can keep an eye on receivables through
a few simple activities. Exception reports
can print out all receivables more than 30
or 60 days old. Generate these reports
weekly for department managers to review
and clear. Maintain an updated list of the
20 oldest receivable balances, indicating
the customers’ names, amounts owed and
current collection status.
The “true worth” of
accounts receivable
worsens as time passes.
Also, institute a credit policy that authorizes a
maximum of two or three people to approve
credit limits for commercial accounts, establishes clear credit restrictions and sets up an
aggressive collection program.
5) Last, hire a top-notch warranty administrator. Aim for a three- to five-day time span
between submitting a claim and getting paid.
Ample cash on hand
Even in a tarnished economy, good management can keep cash flowing. Begin with
an organized system of cash accounts; then
keep your new, used and parts inventory in
tow and, finally, maintain a tight collection
policy. While it’s impossible to anticipate
every receipt of income and every expense,
your steadfastness can ensure that you have
ample cash on hand to meet your daily business needs, obligations and goals. n
How to manage your
online reputation
New media demand fast responses to critics
Car shoppers today can find valuable information on your store through a quick Internet
search. That’s the good news. But they also
can find harsh — sometimes devastating —
words from disgruntled customers who legitimately or not have a bone to pick.
Savvy dealers are proactive about doing what
they can to help make sure that what potential
customers see about their dealerships online is
favorable.
Online word-of-mouth
Specialized rating and review sites, such as
Edmunds, DealerRater and Car Dealer Check,
and general ones, such as Google, Yahoo!,
Angie’s List, Citysearch and Local, are the
new recommendation-giving neighbor next
door. Potential customers’ visits to any of
these sites can quickly include or exclude you
as a possible place to buy their next vehicle.
This is what car shoppers recently could read
about one dealership on a review site:
“The salesman/owner was very deceiving.
He led me to believe that I was purchasing
a car from him with a seven-month warranty.
But upon signing the paper work he said it
was with another company, and it was just
for the engine and transmission. Uh hello,
[the factory] gives you 100,000 mile engine
and transmission warranty so he really gave
me nothing.”
5
6) Worse than the bad review itself,
the dealership received a one-star
rating, because this was the only
review about the business on the
site. And there’s no way to know if
the complaint was justified!
Proactive measures
There are reviews out there more
scathing than the example above,
and one of them could be about
your dealership. So, what can you do
to minimize negative repercussions?
First, you need to find out that
a bad review exists. Some sites
let you arrange for notification if
your business’s name is used in
a review. A “Google alert,” for
example, will inform you when your
dealership’s name is mentioned in
a review, blog or online article.
Your response
Outside help
Some dealerships turn to a professional service to help
them manage their online reputation. Here are a few:
• utoRevenue offers tracking services and will
@
capture positive responses from customers at “key
points in the retention cycle” and get them online.
• XtéresAUTO helps clients track and negate
e
bad reviews by quickly e-mailing the unhappy
customer and trying to rectify the matter.
• resto Reviews helps customers build their own
P
review sites and post both positive and negative
reviews — readers get to see how your dealership
works to turn things around.
If you do use a professional service, be sure to find
out exactly what it will do for you. And, because
your reputation can be damaged in a New York minute, be sure to find out how quickly you’ll have a
chance to turn a bad review around.
Once you’ve spotted a bad review,
the proper response is critical. Although it’s
ideal to respond to an angry customer immediately, take a break from the situation if you
feel the criticism is unfounded and you find
yourself steaming.
If a customer posts a
negative review and it
turns out to be true, fess
up. Have the employee
who met with the customer
respond directly.
When you’ve cooled off, contact the customer
and keep your response simple. Consider just
thanking the customer for the feedback and
choosing your dealership. Trying to defend
your dealership’s actions may only fuel the
6
person’s anger — people who post online are
typically vocal and may well strike back.
If a customer posts a negative review and
it turns out to be true, fess up. Have the
employee who met with the customer
respond directly, admit the mistake and
right the wrong.
Keep in mind that most sites give you the
choice of e-mailing the customer directly
or posting your response for all to see. To
decide, ask yourself if it’s beneficial to your
dealership for potential customers to see
how you responded to the situation.
“A” is for effort
Whatever way you choose to combat negative reviews, you probably won’t be able to
reverse the negative remarks of every customer. But use the tools available to give it
your best shot. n
7) DEALER
DIGEST
Opportunity to correct
worker misclassification
Classifying workers as independent contractors rather than employees can provide dealerships with a number of benefits, including
payroll tax savings. But if you treat someone
as an independent contractor who, under IRS
rules, should be treated as an employee, you
become vulnerable to substantial back taxes,
interest and penalties.
The good news is that, if you’ve mistakenly
classified some workers as independent
contractors, you now have the chance to
reclassify them as employees for future
tax periods without getting a large IRS bill.
Your liability for past payroll tax due can
be reduced to only a minimal payment as
part of the IRS’s new Voluntary Classification
Settlement Program (VCSP).
organization’s most valuable asset. This disconnect isn’t too surprising, given that only
13% of respondents thought a disaster could
happen to them.
The most popular reason given for lacking
a disaster plan was “I haven’t thought about
it” (59%). Maybe it’s time to give thought to
a plan for saving data at your dealership. n
Cell phone use not taxable
The break, however, isn’t available if you’re
already under audit by the IRS or under
audit for the classification of workers by the
Department of Labor or a state agency. For
more on program eligibility requirements and
the IRS rules on classifying workers, consult
your tax advisor. n
If you provide employees with a cell phone
for business, they likely no longer need to
declare the value of
their personal use
of the cell phone
as taxable income,
according to new IRS
guidance. The phone
must not be used as
part of a compensation package or as a
way to attract new
employees or boost
morale. It must be
provided for specific
business reasons,
such as:
Is your data prepared
for a natural disaster?
o ou require that certain employees on
Y
their days off be available to, for example,
answer urgent customer questions or provide input during a deal, or
If you’re like the majority of business
owners responding to a recent survey, the
answer is “no.”
The survey, recently conducted by Carbonite,
a provider of online backup solutions, revealed
that 57% of respondents lacked a disaster
preparedness plan for business data — even
though 81% believed that data was their
o ou need to be able to contact certain
Y
employees at any time for work-related
emergencies, such as missing inventory
or a customer or employee injury.
IRS Notice 2011-72 and a related field audit
memo, dated Sept. 14, also provide guidance
on the reimbursement of the cell phone cost
when the employee provides the phone. n
This publication is distributed with the understanding that the author, publisher and distributor are not rendering legal, accounting or other professional
advice or opinions on specific facts or matters, and, accordingly, assume no liability whatsoever in connection with its use. ©2011 DLRjf12
7